Home ·  Fox Parkersburg ·  My 5
Home  ·   Fox Parkersburg  ·   My5
Illegal ImmigrationWTAP Blog Listing
Illegal Immigration
Topic Author: Roger Sheppard
Posted: 5:35 PM Feb 12, 2008
Replies Posted: 3 comments
Save Email Print
 del.icio.us   Google   Yahoo  digg
Recent Blog Topics
McCain vs. Obama
Release the 9-1-1 Tapes
An Extra 30 Minutes of Olympic Coverage
Most Important election? Maybe yes, maybe no
Farewell to Two WTAP Staffers
Tim Russert's death and the media's reaction
Post Your Comments
First Name:
Email (optional):
Location:
Enter Comments:  
   characters left
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.

Illegal Immigration
The issue of illegal immigration is getting a lot of play in this year's presidential race. And it's bound to get a lot more as November draws closer. It is such a complex issue but I think there are a few key points that must be made. First, we have to face the fact that it would be impossible to find and export every person who is in this country illegally. You can argue about what rights those people should and should not have. But the fact remains: they are here and any effort to round up ALL of them - the ones who work hard and contribute to our economy as well as those who continually break the law ---will bankrupt this nation, turn us into a country of bounty-hunters, or both. Second. Every nation has a right to secure borders. The U.S. has two good reasons to secure its borders. One is to screen and try to prevent terrorists from sneaking into our midst. The second is to prevent an absolute flood of people from over-running this country. Third. If we permit anyone and everyone who wants to come to this country to do so, regardless of their ability to speak English or interest in learning English, we risk creating a permanent under-class of people, who will always have to hide in the shadows and not fully participate in the social life of this country. If they can't vote, if they don't pay taxes, they won't have a legitimate voice in the nation's affairs. And a large number of people, who are denied a legal voice in their country, can turn that country upside down as the gap between the "haves" and the "have-nots" grows ever wider. No one wants to give the estimated 20 million illegal immigrants in this country a free pass toward citizenship or reward them for coming into this country illegally while their fellow countrymen back home have had to wait their turn. But as I said at the beginning, it would be impossible to round them all up and send them back to where they came from. Anyone who thinks that is the answer is out of touch with reality. We must find a way to do the following: 1. Secure our borders to screen for terrorists and to make sure that one population group is not allowed to so freely enter this country, that we have to limit people from other parts of the world who may want to do the same. 2. Send any and all illegal immigrants whom we find breaking minor laws in this country back home, and incarcerate those convicted of committing more serious crimes and ship home when their jail time is finished 3. And create incentives for law-abiding illegals to pay realistic fines and get in line for citizenship. If we fail to bring illegals out of the shadows and get them involved in our laws and our society, we risk the collapse of our country, not from without - but from within.
Read Comments
Posted by: Michael Location: Marietta
The DC political grandstanders who say "ship them all back" should be asked exactly how to round up 11 million people (equal to the population of Ohio) who don't want to be found, then ship them all back across the border. It ain't gonna happen! Secure the borders for real (using the billions saved not trying to round up 11 million fugitives) and then institute a system to have the illegals pay fines, learn English, get in line behind legal immigrants, and let's move on.

Posted by: Blair Couch Location: Vienna
Roger, I think the largest concern I have is that they use governmental services (Schools and Hospitals) without contributing to them (Taxes). We need a way to make them "Legal" and put them in the system. You are dead on about our borders. And there is a fourth reason, to get a handle on the spread of disease. It is just a matter of time before something worse than AIDS hits our society. I would hate to have some terrible disease hit the US and we are unable to get a handle on it because there is a constant flow into our country that we cannot control.

Posted by: Julie Location: Parkersburg
Roger, I agree completely! We need a realistic solution, not just political rhetoric. After living in CA for 20 years, I understand that there are some jobs that illegals do that other citizens simply would not do for the pay offered. Even if we could round up all the illegal aliens, I believe it would cause a serious backlash, especially in the price we pay for our food.